Comparing Passive House standards to baseline codes. Task 2: Multifamily Residential Buildings.

How does Passive House compare with the 2021 IECC and ASHRAE 90.1 for a four-story multifamily building, across climate zones 1 to 7? This study by RDH Building Science models PHI Classic, PHI Low Energy Building, and Phius 2024 Core against those baselines, then tests whether the Passive House results hold when modeled in EnergyPlus.

The whole report is on this page: read it below, with all its tables and figures.

A Passive House Network Report · RDH Building Science for PHN · September 2026 · All reports

The method and model inputs are in Task 1: Methodology & Modeling Parameters.

Cover of Energy Standards Comparison Study, Task 2: Multifamily Residential Buildings

Key findings: the study’s main results, as a PDF.

Key findings (PDF)

The full report as a PDF: fill in the form, and it’s yours to download.

On this page: Executive Summary · 1. Study Background · 2. Study Methodology · 3. Energy Model Inputs · 4. Translation Workflow from Passive House to Hourly Inputs · 5. Findings · 6. Conclusions and Recommendations · See the research

Executive Summary

As policymakers across North America advance low-carbon building policies, incentive programs, and performance-based requirements, they need clear evidence on which compliance pathways can reliably deliver high-performance building outcomes. Passive House is increasingly referenced as a pathway to low-energy and low-carbon buildings, but direct comparison with commonly used code and program baselines is challenging because Passive House, IECC, and ASHRAE 90.1 rely on different modeling tools, assumptions, normalization areas, compliance metrics, and treatment of energy losses.

This study addresses that gap by developing a normalized comparison of selected energy efficiency standards and Passive House pathways for a representative four-story multifamily residential archetype across North American climates (zones 1 to 7). The study compares modeled outcomes for 2021 IECC, ASHRAE 90.1-2016 Appendix G, ASHRAE 90.1-2019 Appendix G, PHI Classic, PHI Low Energy Building, and Phius 2024 Core. Passive House scenarios are then translated into EnergyPlus to assess whether Passive House-level performance can be reproduced in an hourly modeling environment when key inputs, assumptions and modeling protocols are aligned.

Performance Metrics

The central finding is clear: Passive House scenarios produce materially lower modeled energy use than the 2021 IECC and ASHRAE 90.1 2016 and 2019 baseline scenarios for the multifamily archetype reviewed, when modeled in their respective software and associated modeling protocols. As shown in Figure 5.9 (see below), Passive House TEUI (Total Energy Use Intensity) results remain close to 13 kBtu/ft².yr [40 kWh/m².yr] and are relatively stable across climate zones 1 to 7. In comparison, the baseline hourly model scenarios range from approximately 29 to 57 kBtu/ft².yr [90 to 180 kWh/m².yr]. This represents an approximate 2x to 4.5x improvement in total energy use, depending on climate zone and baseline scenario.

Figure 5.9: TEUI and energy generation results for Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.9. TEUI and energy generation results for Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.

Importantly, the results extend beyond total energy use. Passive House scenarios also reduce TEDI and CEDI compared with the baseline hourly model scenarios, indicating lower space heating and cooling demand. This is directly relevant to policy because reduced heating and cooling loads support electrification readiness, peak load reduction, resilience, and improved building robustness across climate conditions.

Focusing on the Passive House pathways, results show that they produce broadly similar whole-building energy outcomes for the archetype studied. PHI Classic, PHI Low Energy Building, and Phius 2024 Core differ in methodology, compliance thresholds, and modeling tools, but their TEUI results remain low and relatively close across climate zones 1 to 7.

Passive House-to-Hourly Translation

The Passive House-to-hourly translation workflow provides an additional policy-relevant finding. When Passive House-compliant inputs and protocols are translated into EnergyPlus, the hourly TEUI values remained closely aligned with the original Passive House software results. This indicates that Passive House-level TEUI outcomes are not simply an artifact of Passive House-specific software. Rather, when inputs and assumptions are carefully normalized, different engines (hourly and Passive House) can be configured to represent Passive House-level total energy performance with a high degree of consistency. This supports recognizing Passive House as a robust alternative compliance pathway for policies, incentive programs, and performance-based building requirements where the objective is to achieve predictable, high-performance energy outcomes.

At the same time, comparable TEUI results should not be interpreted as full alignment across all metrics or end uses. The translated Passive House scenarios produced closely aligned whole-building TEUI outcomes, but notable software-specific differences remain at the TEDI, CEDI, and end-use levels. Heating demand alignment was closer for PHI Classic than for Phius 2024 Core in colder climates, while translated cooling demand results were generally higher than the corresponding Passive House software results. These differences reflect the impact of software engines, calculation methods, the ability to zone, model partial load and calculate hourly heat balance for hourly software, and the treatment of losses.

The study also shows that plug loads, lighting, elevators, fans, pumps, and domestic hot water assumptions have a material influence on TEUI and should not be treated as neutral background inputs. Plug loads represent a major share of total energy use, and assumptions in plug load, lighting, and elevator energy use vary significantly between modeling protocols – with all these inputs affecting internal gains, which in turn influence heating and cooling demand.

The in-depth analysis and explanations of software-specific differences at the end-use level, alongside the alignment of TEUI results supports the credibility of the comparison, supporting the use of a robust translation workflow for policy comparison and review.

Modeling Software & Methodologies

Overall, the study reinforces that modeled results should be understood in a “tool + modeling protocol” context. Passive House tools and protocols place greater emphasis on airtightness verification, thermal bridging, shading, ventilation heat recovery, and explicit accounting for hydronic distribution and installation losses. Hourly models provide greater granularity through hourly time steps, zoning, and HVAC part-load performance, but may exclude or simplify certain loss mechanisms depending on the protocol and model setup. Floor area definitions also differ across tools and must be normalized to support like-for-like comparison. Therefore, tools and protocols should be explicitly named when energy model results are used for policy, program, or lending decisions.

Policy Implications

Based on these findings, Passive House should be accepted as an alternative compliance pathway for energy efficiency policies, incentive programs, and performance-based building requirements where the objective is to achieve predictable, high-performance energy outcomes. For the archetype and climates studied, Passive House does not merely perform comparably to the selected code and program baselines; it delivers substantially lower modeled TEUI, TEDI, and CEDI outcomes.

Passive House certification also includes an important quality-assurance dimension that is not fully captured by desk-based modeling comparisons. Passive House projects require detailed energy model review, documentation of key assumptions,

airtightness testing, in-depth commissioning, and construction-phase quality assurance to help verify through a third-party that design intent is carried through into construction. This differentiates Passive House from non-Passive House pathways where modeled performance is not supported by the same level of field verification or certification review.

For policymakers, program administrators, and lending institutions, the implication is direct: Passive House is a credible, robust, and proven high-performance alternative compliance pathway and should be recognized as such in policies, incentive programs, financing eligibility criteria, and performance-based building requirements.

Further Analysis

This study is a desk-based modeling analysis. This approach allows multiple tools, standards, climates, and assumptions to be compared under controlled conditions, but it does not capture all factors that influence actual building performance, such as construction quality, commissioning, controls setup, maintenance, operating practices, and occupant behavior. A key next step is to test these modeled trends against measured building performance. Relevant data already exists for certified Passive House projects (P HI and Phius standards) and for non-Passive House buildings through benchmarking platforms and disclosure datasets (e.g., ENERGY STAR Portfolio Manager). To support meaningful comparison, these dispersed datasets would need to be amalgamated and normalized to develop a robust measured comparison graph for Passive House, IECC, and ASHRAE-based projects. Whole-building TEUI is likely the most accessible near-term operational metric, while sub-metered or otherwise disaggregated data per end-use would allow a more detailed comparison with modeled assumptions.

1. Study Background

As policymakers across North America accelerate toward low-carbon buildings, the numerous design and modeling approaches, certifications, and standards variety can be challenging to navigate. The Passive House Network (PHN) seeks to provide a clear understanding of key energy efficiency standards that will empower policymakers to design programs, incentives, and policies that drive toward low-carbon buildings with a reliable understanding of the outcomes.

Passive House has increasingly been referenced by jurisdictions, program administrators, and industry stakeholders as a pathway to achieve high-performance and low-carbon building outcomes. However, because Passive House certification frameworks and common energy efficiency standards rely on different modeling tools, assumptions, compliance metrics, and reporting conventions, their relative performance outcomes are not always directly comparable. This study addresses that gap by establishing a rigorous, normalized comparison framework for a representative multifamily archetype across North American climate zones, allowing the Passive House outcomes to be assessed alongside commonly used code and program pathways (IECC, ASHRAE 90.1) in a consistent manner.

1.1. Objectives of the Study

The objectives of this study are as follows:

  • Understand and document the impact of the choice for modeling tools.
  • Assess how Passive House standards compare relative to code-minimum and other performance-based pathways.
  • Clarify the energy efficiency landscape, to empower policy makers to make informed choices in investment, guidelines, incentives, policies and code.
  • Support Passive House as an alternative compliance pathway.

2. Study Methodology

This study builds on the initial report “Energy Standards Comparison Study – Task 1: Study Methodology”, issued in September 2023.

2.1. Typology

This phase of the study is focused on the Multi-Family (MF) Residential building type. The building was defined based on a mid-rise apartment archetype as developed by the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL). Key building characteristics are listed below:

  • Number of stories: 4
  • Number of apartments: 31
  • Building use: apartments 78%, corridor 10%, office 3%
  • Orientation: long sides facing north/south
  • Other key characteristics: 20% Window-to-Wall Ratio, Vertical surface area-to-Floor Area Ratio (VFAR): 0.49
Figure 2.1: PNNL Multi-Family Residential Building archetype.
Figure 2.1. PNNL Multi-Family Residential Building archetype.

2.2. Geographic Location

The study expands through the 7 primary climate zones in North America (excluding climate zone 8). The following locations were selected during the “Task 1: Study Methodology” to represent each climate zone.

Figure 2.2: Location of energy models captured in the study.
Figure 2.2. Location of energy models captured in the study.

Table 1.1 Geographic location for energy models

Climate Zone Locations used for Hourly Modeling Location used for Passive House Modeling

CZ 1

Honolulu, HI (1A)

Miami, FL (1A)

CZ 2

Austin, TX (2A)

Tampa, FL (2A)

Tucson, AZ (2B)

Houston, TX (2A)

CZ 3

Memphis, TN (3A)

El Paso, TX (3B)

Atlanta, GA (3A)

CZ 4

Baltimore, MD (4A)

New York, NY (4A)

Pittsburgh, PA (4A)

Albuquerque, NM (4B)

Seattle, WA (4C)

Philadelphia, PA (4A)

CZ 5

Boston, MA (5A)

Buffalo, NY (5A)

Denver, CO (5B)

Port Angeles, WA (5C)

Chicago, IL (5A)

CZ 6

Burlington, VT (6A)

Portland, ME (6A)

Rochester, MN (6A)

Bozeman, MT (6B)

Minneapolis, MN (6A)

CZ 7

Aspen, CO (7)

International Falls, MN (7)

Duluth, MN (7)

2.3. Modeling Tools & Scenarios

The archetype building is modeled in both hourly and Passive House modeling software, to meet the list of standards below. Passive House inputs are then systematically translated into hourly energy model inputs to allow for a comparison of building performance metrics between tools.

2.3.1. Hourly Energy Models

The whole-building software used for hourly modeling is EnergyPlus version 22.1. Energy models are run to the following widely used standards, according to their respective modeling methodology.

Table 2.2 Hourly energy model cases

Standard Description Typical Objective

IECC*

2021 IECC

IECC baseline

ASHRAE 90.1**

ASHRAE 90.1-2016 Appendix G

LEED baseline

ASHRAE 90.1**

ASHRAE 90.1-2019 Appendix G

To assess LEED Building Design + Construction v4.1 energy efficiency points vs ASHRAE 90.1-2016 Appendix G reference

*IECC: International Energy Conservation Code. **ASHRAE: American Society of Heating, Refrigeration and Air-Conditioning Engineers, with ASHRAE 90.1 standard: Energy Standard for Buildings Except Low-Rise Residential Buildings.

IECC versions have evolved over the years. 2012 IECC is accepted as one of the starting points for modern whole-building energy modeling. Each version of the IECC (respectively 2015, 2018, and 2021) has introduced more rigorous performance requirements, notably in envelope performance, HVAC efficiency, and air leakage control. The 2021 IECC is the most stringent one to date (at the start of the study).

2.3.2. Passive House Energy Models

The whole-building software used for Passive House modeling is:

  • Passive House Planning Package (PHPP) v10 for certification to the Passive House Institute’s standard (PHI), and
  • WUFI-Passive (W-PH) v3.5.0.1 for certification to the Passive House Institute U.S. (Phius).

Energy models are run to the following Passive House standards, according to their respective modeling methodology.

Table 2.3 Passive House energy model cases

Standard Description Objective

PHI

PHI Classic

Compliance – most stringent PHI certification

PHI

PHI Low Energy Building (LEB)

Compliance

Phius

Phius 2024 Core

Compliance

PHI

PHI Classic

Compliance – addition of renewables on PHI Classic for energy balance

Phius

Phius 2024 Zero

Compliance – addition of renewables on Phius 2024 Core for energy balance

2.3.3. “Translated” Passive House Energy Models in EnergyPlus

The whole-building software used for the “translated” Passive House models is the hourly modeling software, EnergyPlus. Energy models are run for the following cases.

Table 2.4 “Translated” Passive House energy model cases in EnergyPlus

Software Description Objective

EnergyPlus

PHI Classic in EnergyPlus

Comparison to PHI Classic results in PHPP software

EnergyPlus

Phius 2024 Core in EnergyPlus

Comparison to Phius 2024 Core results in W-PH software

2.4. Performance Metrics

At the core of this study is the aim to provide quantitative, like-for-like comparison – to the best of the software abilities and limitations – between widely used standards which are difficult to compare. To provide a meaningful comparison, all energy model outputs are therefore normalized against a common floor area (labeled Gross Floor Area – GFA in this study):

  • Normalized Thermal Energy Demand Intensity (TEDI), in kBtu/ft².yr [kWh/m².yr],
  • Normalized Cooling Energy Demand Intensity (CEDI), in kBtu/ft².yr [kWh/m².yr], and
  • Normalized Total Energy Use Intensity (TEUI), in kBtu/ft².yr [kWh/m².yr].

3. Energy Model Inputs

Energy modeling involves numerous inputs, making direct comparisons challenging if a multitude of variables are moving at once. To ensure clarity in results and ease of analysis, the approach throughout the study minimizes changes to input variables, maintaining consistent system design and performance requirements across modeling cases, where feasible.

Note: There are many valid approaches to achieving comparable building performance metrics to meet the modeled standards. The choices made in this study support methodological consistency and are not intended to represent the preferred, or only solution.

Table 3.1 below provides an overview of the fixed versus variable inputs in the modeled files, with the driver for each variable. More detailed information on variables, and their associated range, is provided in the rest of section 3.

Table 3.1 Overview of fixed & variable model inputs

Software EnergyPlus PHPP W-PH

Model Scenarios

2021 IECC

ASHRAE 2016

ASHRAE 2019

PHI Classic

PHI LEB

PHI Classic Plus

Phius 2024 Core

Phius 2024 Zero

Fixed inputs across software

Building typology, massing, orientation, use/occupancy (and associated schedules/loads)

Variables across software

Variables – set by PNNL

  • Building enclosure, inc. windows (by climate zone)
  • Infiltration (by standard)
  • HVAC and DHW system types (by standard and by climate zone)
  • Lighting Power Densities (by standard)

Fixed Inputs

  • Thermal bridging
  • Ventilation approach
  • HVAC and DHW system types
  • Lighting and plug loads

Variables – driven by study

  • Building enclosure, inc. windows (by climate zone)
  • Window solar heat gain coefficient (by climate zone)
  • Infiltration (by standard, and climate zone)
  • Ventilation heat recovery efficiency (by climate zone)

3.1. Hourly Models Inputs & Adjustments

3.1.1. Baseline Hourly Model Input Adjustments

The baseline hourly models relate to the 2021 IECC, ASHRAE 90.1-2016 Appendix G and 90.1-2019 Appendix G prototype scenarios.

The technical review of baseline model inputs in these files revealed that these energy models lacked corridor ventilation and space conditioning (heating, cooling). Unconditioned corridors do not reflect current new-construction standards and do not comply with ASHRAE 62.1 minimum ventilation requirements. The industry-standard approach is to design corridors to be served by Make-Up Air Units (MUA) with supplementary heating and cooling.

To provide a like-for-like comparison, where all spaces within the thermal enclosure are conditioned (consistent indoor environment expectations between scenarios), the baseline models were adjusted to include corridor ventilation and associated required space conditioning. Table 3.2 provides a summary of the energy model inputs used to define the corridor ventilation and heating system.

Table 3.2 Hourly model inputs – corridor system adjustments

Element Proposed Units Reference/Description
Ventilation System

System

Make-up air unit

One per corridor level

Design Air Flow

0.06 [1.1]

cfm/ft² [(m³/hr)/m²]

ASHRAE 62.1-2016

Outdoor air fraction

100

%

Outdoor air volume control

Constant

System Total Fan Power

~0.133 [0.078]

W/cfm [W/(m³/hr)]

Typical

Economizer

None

–

Heat recovery

None

%

Zone Heating/Cooling Devices

System

Electric Baseboards

3.1.2. Baseline Hourly Model Inputs

Aside from the change to the corridors noted in the previous section, the baseline hourly models as is. Key characteristics of these prototype models are presented in Table 3.3 below.

Table 3.3 Hourly model inputs – key characteristics (reference)

Element IECC 2021 ASHRAE 90.1-2016 Appendix G ASHRAE 90.1-2019 Appendix G

Opaque enclosure R-value (ft²·F·h/BTU) [m²·K/W]

R-7.6 to R-10.3

[1.34 to 1.82]

R-5.8 to R-10.9

[1.02 to 1.92]

R-5.8 to R-10.9

[1.02 to 1.92]

Window U-value (Btu/(h·ft²·°F)) [W/m²·K]

U-0.31 to U-0.53

[1.76 to 3.01]

U-0.33 to U-0.57

[1.87 to 3.24]

U-0.31 to U-0.53

[1.76 to 3.01]

Windows SHGC (whole-window)

0.23 to 0.40

0.25 to 0.45

0.23 to 0.40

Thermal Bridging

Not explicitly considered

Not explicitly considered

Not explicitly considered

Infiltration (cfm/ft²) [(m³/hr)/m²] @ operating pressure modified by wind coefficient (0.224)

0.030 [0.55]

0.050 [0.91]

0.050 [0.91]

Ventilation Heat Recovery

Varies by climate zone

60–66%

No heat recovery on most systems

Varies by climate zone

60–66%

Apartment Lighting Power Density (Btu/(h·ft²)) [W/m²]

1.36 [4.3]

2.06 [6.5]

1.74 [5.5]

Apartment Plug Load Density (Btu/(h·ft²)) [W/m²]

2.12 [6.7]

2.12 [6.7]

2.12 [6.7]

Apartment Ventilation (cfm/ft²) [(m³/hr)/m²]

0.060 [1.10]

0.060 [1.10]

0.060 [1.10]

Apartment Heating/Cooling

Gas Heating

DX Cooling

Gas or DX Heating (varies by climate zone)

DX Cooling

Gas or DX Heating (varies by climate zone)

DX Cooling

Domestic Hot Water

Electric Heating or Heat Pump

Gas Heating

Gas Heating

3.2. Passive House Models Inputs & Adjustments

All Passive House models are required to demonstrate compliance with their associated Passive House performance requirements for certification. All system performances were improved to achieve Passive House compliance. As per the overall study, the approach to minimize changes to input variables is maintained.

All variables within Passive House scenarios are listed in Table 3.4, all other inputs listed in Table 3.5 are fixed between Passive House energy model scenarios.

Table 3.4 Passive House model inputs – variables

Element PHI Classic PHI LEB Phius 2024 Core

Walls R-value (clear-field, ft²·F·h/BTU) [m²·K/W]

R-21 to R-65

[3.70 to 11.45]

R-6 to R-54

[1.06 to 9.51]

R-5 to R-28

[0.88 to 4.93]

Roof R-value (clear-field, ft²·F·h/BTU) [m²·K/W]

R-30 to R-60

[5.28 to 10.57]

R-11 to R-60

[1.94 to 10.57]

R-10 to R-38

[1.76 to 6.69]

Floor R-value (clear-field, ft²·F·h/BTU) [m²·K/W]

R-20 to R-40

[3.52 to 7.04]

R-10 to R-40

[1.76 to 7.04]

R-5 to R-19

[0.88 to 3.35]

Windows U-value, installed (Btu/(h·ft²·°F)) [W/m²·K]

U-0.14

[0.77 to 0.81]

U-0.19

[1.07]

U-0.17 to U-0.18

[0.94 to 1.00]

Windows SHGC (center-of-glass, COG)

0.17 to 0.56

0.20 to 0.40

0.15 to 0.23

Air Permeability (cfm/ft² @50Pa) [(m³/hr)/m² @50Pa]

0.039–0.079

[0.72–1.44]

0.13

[2.40]

0.060

[1.10]

Infiltration (ACH @50Pa)

0.3–0.6

1.00

0.46

Table 3.5 Passive House model inputs – key characteristics

Element Approach Notes

Thermal bridging

Mitigated to achieve good practice

Ventilation

Apartment: in-suite ERV

Corridor: ERV

Average ventilation rate: 0.46 ACH

Ventilation heat recovery efficiency

81–86% sensible

71–73% latent

Product variation between hot & cold climate

Dehumidification

Dehumidifier (where required)

Heating/Cooling system

Air source heat pump

Heating/Cooling distribution

Hydronic distribution, with Fan Coil Unit

Domestic Hot Water

In-suite heat pump water heater

Lighting, Plug loads, Process loads

Good practice

4. Translation Workflow from Passive House to Hourly Inputs

4.1. Software Modeling Methodology Key Differences

Different modeling programs reference unique modeling protocols with respective standard inputs and assumptions. Table 4.1 summarizes key differences between software/modeling methodologies (refer to the initial phase this study: “Energy Standards Comparison Study – Task 1: Study Methodology”).

Table 4.1 Overview of software key modeling differences

Characteristic EnergyPlus PHPP W-PH

Software type

Hourly

Monthly

Monthly

Zoning

Multi-zone

Single-zone

Single-zone

Floor Area

Gross Floor Area (GFA)

Treated Floor Area (TFA)

Interior Conditioned Floor Area (iCFA)

Infiltration

Assumed (not verified)

Tested

Tested

Thermal Bridging

Usually excluded

Accounted

Accounted

Shading

Adjacent buildings unaccounted

Adjacent buildings accounted

Adjacent buildings accounted

ERV Installation

Duct heat losses unaccounted

Duct heat losses accounted

Duct heat losses accounted

HVAC Part Load

Modeled

Limited tools

Limited tools

DHW Distribution

Circulation & distribution heat losses unaccounted

Circulation and distribution heat losses accounted

Circulation and distribution heat losses accounted

4.2. Translation Approach

One of the primary objectives of this study is to compare Passive House and hourly whole-building energy modeling software when modeling high-performance buildings with a consistent modeling approach. The next step of the study, described in this section, is the translation of Passive House inputs into hourly inputs, through a practical input-alignment workflow, prior to running Passive House scenarios into the hourly program (EnergyPlus) and comparing building performance metrics.

The goal of this translation is to use Passive House-compliant inputs and modeling protocols to run Passive House scenarios in the Hourly software (EnergyPlus). The following approach was taken in the translation workflow:

  • Building characteristics: both software runs (hourly and Passive House) use identical building typology, size, massing, and orientation.
  • Weather normalization: both software run using the hourly weather files.
  • Hourly algorithms: Passive House run in hourly software to use default hourly software algorithms, with adjusted inputs (see next point), where this approach is feasible. This approach includes the calculations of internal heat gains, the impact of surrounding grounds, etc.
  • Alignment of modeling methodologies, leading to adjusted Passive House inputs into hourly software: a consistent modeling methodology is at the core of providing a meaningful comparison between the Passive House scenarios run in both Passive House and hourly modeling software. This alignment includes alignment of thermal bridging, shading, average occupancy, etc.

Table 4.2 below describes the translation of Passive House inputs into hourly inputs, within the limitations and differences between both energy modeling programs.

Table 4.2 Summary of translated Passive House inputs into hourly model inputs

Element Passive House Inputs Translated Inputs
General

Climate

–

Use of 2021 IECC weather files.

People

Approach: occupancy density based on a function of floor area and number of dwelling units.

Model input: average occupancy.

Approach: adjusted peak occupancy density (combined with hourly schedules) to align with Passive House average occupancy.

Model input: adjusted peak occupancy.

Set points

Model input: fixed value for heating and cooling.

Model input: fixed values to match Passive House inputs.

Building enclosure

Walls/Roof U-Value

Approach: modeled U-value includes impact of surface resistance (Rsi, Rse).

Approach:

  • Assembly clear-field R-value aligned with Passive House inputs,
  • With adjustment to remove the impact of surface resistance (as impact of “air films” separately accounted in software)

Model input: adjusted clear-field R-value.

Floor U-Value

Approach: impact of surrounding ground calculated separately based on other model inputs.

Model input: value excluding impact of surrounding ground.

Approach: similar to Passive House. Separate algorithm applying the impact of surrounding ground.

Model input: value accounting for reduction factor in alignment with PHPP. Impact of surrounding ground temperature accounted for in simulation.

Window U-value

Approach: impact of window installation (thermal bridging) accounted.

Model input: separate inputs for glazing, frame, spacer and installation performance inputs.

Approach: overall window U-value calculated based on project-specific sizes, combining performance of the glazing, frame, spacer and window installation (with all performance values aligned with Passive House inputs).

Model input: adjusted installed window U-value (combined input).

Window SHGC

Model input: COG SHGC.

Approach: use of COG SHGC into window SHGC, including impact of frame, based on project-specific window size.

Model input: window SHGC calculated, based on matching Passive House COG SHGC value and project-specific size.

Shading

Approach: impact of shading from adjacent external surroundings on TEDI calculation.

Model input: Passive House default reduction factor due to external shading.

Approach: addition of shading impact of adjacent external surroundings.

Model input: SHGC adjusted to account for PHPP equivalent shading in winter months.

Thermal bridging

Model inputs:

  • Separate thermal bridging entries,
  • Based on external dimension approach to heat loss surface area measurements.

Approach:

  • Impact of linear non-repeating thermal bridging at junction allocated to surface element (wall, roof, floor) to move from a clear-field R-value to a whole-field R-value.
  • Adjustments to reflect difference in approach to heat loss surface area measurements.

Model inputs: adjusted opaque element R-values. All non-window associated thermal bridges applied to modeled wall performance

Infiltration

Model input: constant airtightness performance.

Approach:

  • Total infiltration rate in alignment with Passive House airtightness requirements,
  • With conversion to external vertical surface area (to fit software algorithm).

Model input: adjusted constant infiltration rate.

HVAC

Outdoor air flow rates

Approach: based on Passive House default ventilation rates, as a function of space type and occupancy.

Approach: adjusted flow rates to match average Passive House outdoor air flow rates.

Model input: adjusted constant flow rate input.

ERV efficiency

Approach:

  • Efficiency calculated following Passive House methodology.
  • Separate software calculation to account for impact of installation (duct losses between ERV and thermal enclosure).

Model input: separate inputs for theoretical ERV efficiency, and characteristics of duct distribution losses.

Approach: combined overall ERV efficiency, combining the theoretical efficiency with the impact of installation (with all performance values aligned with Passive House inputs).

Model input: adjusted overall ERV efficiency (combined input).

Fan power (ERV, FCU)

Approach: constant specific fan power (expressed in W/(m³/hr)) for ERV fans and Fan Coil Unit fans, applied to respective flow rate.

Model input: specific fan power.

Approach:

  • ERV fans: adjusted fan static pressure and efficiency values (applied to hourly schedules) to match average total fan specific fan power.
  • FCU fans: adjusted fan static pressure and efficiency values (applied to hourly loads) to match average total fan wattage.

Model input: adjusted fan static pressure and efficiency values.

Natural ventilation

Model input: not modeled in study

Model input: no natural ventilation modeled

Heating/Cooling

Approach: high-level feasibility study, with simplified approach to equipment seasonal efficiency, modeled with constant seasonal COP.

Model input: constant seasonal COP.

Approach: seasonal efficiency of the heating, cooling, and DHW modified in a post processing calculation, to match Passive House performance values.

Model input: constant seasonal COP.

DHW, lighting, plug loads

DHW demand

Model input: based on Passive House default DHW demand.

Approach: adjusted peak flow rates (applied to hourly schedules) to match average Passive House DHW demand.

Model input: adjusted peak values.

DHW system

Approach: impact of distribution and storage losses accounted in DHW energy end use.

Model input: separate inputs for distribution system and storage heat loss characteristics.

Approach: adjusted peak flow rates (applied to hourly schedules) to add the impact of distribution and storage losses, to match Passive House DHW system losses.

Model input: adjusted peak values.

Pump power

Approach: constant pump power, applied to respective demand.

Model input: individual pump power.

Approach: pump energy use simplified to align with annual PHPP pump energy use.

Model input: pump energy use modeled as electric equipment.

Plug Loads, Elevator, and Interior Lighting

Approach: calculated annually based on applicable appliances/equipment loads and standardized utilization, as a function of space type and occupancy.

Model input: annual average power density.

Approach: adjusted peak load (applied to standardized fractional hourly schedules) to match annual Passive House total energy end use – separately for plug loads, elevator usage and interior lighting.

Model input: adjusted peak values.

5. Findings

Results from all models (hourly, Passive House, and Passive House scenarios in hourly software) are analyzed and compared.

5.1. Addition of Corridor Space Conditioning

As noted in Section 3.1.1, the baseline hourly models were adjusted to include corridor ventilation and associated space conditioning. This adjustment was introduced to better reflect a conditioned multifamily building baseline and to provide a consistent basis for comparison across subsequent modeling scenarios.

The impact of this adjustment was assessed using the Denver, Colorado model, representing climate zone 5B. The comparison evaluates the change in normalized heating demand, cooling demand, and total energy use before and after adding corridor ventilation and space conditioning. The results are shown in Figure 5.1.

The addition of corridor ventilation and space conditioning increased both the TEDI and TEUI metrics, as expected. However, the magnitude of the increase is limited, indicating that the corridor adjustment has a relatively small impact on overall building performance for the tested model.

Figure 5.1: Performance Metrics of the 2021 IECC models without (left) and with (right) corridor ventilation, for Denver (climate zone 5B).
Figure 5.1. Performance Metrics of the 2021 IECC models without (left) and with (right) corridor ventilation, for Denver (climate zone 5B).

5.2. Baseline Hourly Energy Models

The baseline hourly energy models were evaluated for the 2021 IECC, ASHRAE 90.1-2016 Appendix G, and ASHRAE 90.1-2019 Appendix G scenarios, with the corridor ventilation and space conditioning adjustment described in Section 3.1.1 included in each case.

Thermal Energy Demand Intensity (TEDI)

For heating demand, the ASHRAE 90.1-2016 scenario generally represents the highest-demand baseline (i.e., least efficient baseline). This is primarily driven by the absence of ventilation heat recovery in HVAC systems, which increases the modeled heating load relative to the other hourly scenarios.

Cooling Energy Demand Intensity (CEDI)

The 2021 IECC scenario generally shows the highest normalized cooling demand among the hourly models (i.e., least efficient baseline). This is understood to be related to the relative balance of internal loads, envelope performance, ventilation assumptions, and cooling system operation in the prototype models.

Total Energy Use Intensity

  • ASHRAE 90.1-2016 scenarios display the highest total energy consumption, due to the absence of ventilation heat recovery.
  • 2021 IECC scenarios display the lowest total energy consumption.
  • ASHRAE 90.1-2019 results fall between these two scenarios, with results closer to ASHRAE 90.1-2016 in warmer climates and closer to 2021 IECC in colder climates.

Across the baseline hourly scenarios, TEUI results range from approximately 29 to 57 kBtu/ft².yr [90 to 180 kWh/m².yr] (with the lower end associated with 2021 IECC scenarios, and the upper end with ASHRAE 90.1-2016 scenarios). On average, the ASHRAE 90.1-2016 Appendix G baseline increases TEUI relative to the 2021 IECC baseline by approximately 15% to 40%, depending on climate zone (the highest difference experienced in climate zone 4).

Figure 5.2: TEDI results for baseline hourly model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.2. TEDI results for baseline hourly model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.3: CEDI results for baseline hourly model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.3. CEDI results for baseline hourly model scenarios, across climate zones.

Overall, the hourly model results demonstrate that the selected baseline standard and associated modeling protocol materially influence reported performance outcomes, even when the same building archetype and general modeling platform are used. The differences are not driven by a single input; rather, they reflect the combined effect of envelope requirements, infiltration assumptions, ventilation heat recovery, internal loads, HVAC system assumptions, and the treatment of losses that are included or excluded under each modeling protocol.

Figure 5.4: TEUI results for baseline hourly model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.4. TEUI results for baseline hourly model scenarios, across climate zones.

5.3. Passive House Energy Models

The Passive House energy models were evaluated for the PHI Classic, PHI Low Energy Building, and Phius 2024 Core scenarios in their respective modeling software, including 2 scenarios with energy generation: PHI Classic Plus and Phius 2024 Zero.

Thermal Energy Demand Intensity (TEDI) and Cooling Energy Demand Intensity (CEDI)

Across the Passive House scenarios, normalized space conditioning demands are substantially lower than the baseline hourly model results presented in Section 5.2.

  • PHI Classic generally produces the lowest TEDI results, and PHI Low Energy Building generally produces the highest TEDI results. However, results remain low in absolute terms and are generally at or below 6 kBtu/ft².yr [20 kWh/m².yr]. Phius 2024 Core falls between PHI Classic and PHI Low Energy Building for heating demand.
  • PHI Classic generally produces the lowest CEDI results, and Phius 2024 Core the highest CEDI results. The higher Phius CEDI results appear to be related to the combination of higher internal loads and less stringent enclosure performance relative to PHI Classic. PHI Low Energy Building generally falls between these two scenarios for cooling demand.

PHI space conditioning targets are set, independently from the building massing. Phius’ approach to space conditioning targets differs, with performance requirements being influenced by building massing and compactness. The study archetype has a relatively compact form factor, which supports lower space conditioning targets set for Phius compliance. A less compact building form could result in less stringent Phius space conditioning targets.

Across the baseline Passive House scenarios, TEDI and CEDI results are significantly reduced from the hourly baselines.

Figure 5.5: TEDI and CEDI results for Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.5. TEDI and CEDI results for Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.

Total Energy Use Intensity (TEUI)

TEUI results are closely grouped across all Passive House scenarios. PHI Classic generally produces the lowest TEUI, PHI Low Energy Building generally produces the highest TEUI, and Phius 2024 Core generally falls between the two. The difference between scenarios is limited in absolute terms, with all Passive House TEUI results approximately 13 kBtu/ft².yr [40 kWh/m².yr] and within approximately 10% of each other.

On-Site and Off-Site Generation

For the energy-generation scenarios, the treatment of renewable generation differs between Passive House frameworks.

  • To achieve Phius 2024 Zero compliance, generation is sized to offset modeled annual energy consumption (with on-site production, combined with off-site renewable as required). Therefore, the generation demand varies across climate zones.
  • To achieve PHI Classic Plus compliance, a minimum energy generation threshold needs to be met. For this study, an identical roof-mounted solar array is applied across climate zones, resulting in climate-dependent variation in annual generation.

Across the Passive House energy-generation cases, annual generation is closely aligned with the total annual energy use, around 13 kBtu/ft².yr [40 kWh/m².yr] (production and generation respectively). This is consistent with the accepted industry definition of “Net Zero Energy” buildings, where annual renewable energy generation matches the annual building energy consumption.

Figure 5.6: TEUI and energy generation results for Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.6. TEUI and energy generation results for Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.

The low and relatively narrow TEUI range indicates that, for this archetype, all three Passive House scenarios deliver broadly similar total energy outcomes despite differences in certification methodology, input assumptions, and compliance thresholds.

5.4. Initial Comparison of Hourly & Passive House Models

Hourly and Passive House scenarios, run in their respective software, are first compared without any adjustments, except for the floor area normalization. The results therefore reflect both the performance requirements of each standard and the methodology embedded in each modeling platform.

Across all three performance metrics, the Passive House scenarios show substantially lower results than the hourly baseline scenarios, consistently across climate zones. This trend is most apparent for the Total Energy Use Intensity (TEUI) metric, where the baseline hourly scenarios range from approximately 29 to 57 kBtu/ft².yr [90 to 180 kWh/m².yr], compared with Passive House scenarios that are close to 13 kBtu/ft².yr [40 kWh/m².yr] mark (i.e., a 2 x to 4.5 x improvement, varying by climate zone). These consistent improvements show the combined effect of reduced space conditioning loads, high-efficiency

ventilation heat recovery, efficient heating/cooling systems, and lower regulated loads, which can materially reduce whole-building energy consumption for the multi-family archetype.

Figure 5.7: TEDI results for baseline hourly model scenarios and Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.7. TEDI results for baseline hourly model scenarios and Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.8: CEDI results for baseline hourly model scenarios and Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.8. CEDI results for baseline hourly model scenarios and Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.9: TEUI and energy generation results for Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.
Figure 5.9. TEUI and energy generation results for Passive House model scenarios, across climate zones.

5.5. “Translated” Passive House Energy Models into Hourly Software

Differences between the results from the hourly (IECC and ASHRAE) and Passive House (PHI and Phius) standards include both differences in standard performance requirements and differences in modeling methodology, including treatment of floor area, thermal bridging, internal gains, ventilation, equipment performance, and distribution losses.

The final stage of the study is the translation of Passive House inputs into Hourly inputs following the approach detailed in Section 4, to obtain a normalized software-to-software assessment.

  • Building performance metrics (TEDI, CEDI, TEUI) are first compared between the original IECC Hourly scenario and the Passive House scenarios in both the hourly software versus Passive House software.
  • End-use energy consumption is then also compared, to provide more insight into each scenario.

The results are displayed for the Passive House Classic (PHPP) standard in Section 5.5.1, followed by the Phius 2024 Core (W-PH) standard in Section 5.5.2.

5.5.1. Passive House Classic (PHPP) Results

Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [1A] Miami: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [1A] Miami
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [2A] Houston: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [2A] Houston
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [3A] Atlanta: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [3A] Atlanta
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [4A] Philadelphia: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [4A] Philadelphia
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [5A] Chicago: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [5A] Chicago
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [6A] Minneapolis: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [6A] Minneapolis
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [7A] Duluth: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – PHI Classic: [7A] Duluth

5.5.2. Phius 2024 Core (W-PH) Results

Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [1A] Miami: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [1A] Miami
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [2A] Houston: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [2A] Houston
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [3A] Atlanta: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [3A] Atlanta
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [4A] Philadelphia: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [4A] Philadelphia
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [5A] Chicago: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [5A] Chicago
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [6A] Minneapolis: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [6A] Minneapolis
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [7A] Duluth: TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI, and the end-use breakdown
Hourly vs Passive Software – Phius 2024 Core: [7A] Duluth

5.5.3. Analysis of Passive House to Hourly Modeling Results

The results are analyzed for all climate zones, illustrated with example graphs to help with visualization.

Total Energy Use Intensity (TEUI)

Figure 5.10: Performance metrics of IECC scenarios in climate zone 5A [Chicago] against Passive House scenarios, in both their respective software (PHPP, W-PH) and hourly software.
Figure 5.10. Performance metrics of IECC scenarios in climate zone 5A [Chicago] against Passive House scenarios, in both their respective software (PHPP, W-PH) and hourly software.

The initial comparison presented in Section 5.4 showed a substantial difference between the baseline hourly scenarios and the Passive House scenarios, with Passive House TEUI results around 13 kBtu/ft².yr [40 kWh/m².yr].

The translated Passive House results presented in Sections 5.5.1 and 5.5.2 show that, once Passive House inputs and modeling assumptions are translated into EnergyPlus, the resulting TEUI values in EnergyPlus remain closely aligned with the original Passive House software results from both PHPP (PHI Classic) and WUFI Passive (Phius 2024 Core) software. Across the climate zones reviewed, the translated EnergyPlus results track the Passive House software results within a narrow range, with the maximum divergence from the corresponding PHPP or W-PH result appearing to remain within ±5% (i.e., within 0.6 kBtu/ft².yr [2 kWh/m².yr]). This indicates that the translation workflow is producing comparable whole-building energy outcomes, despite the different calculation engines used by the hourly and Passive House tools.

However, the close TEUI agreement of Passive House scenarios through the various software should not be interpreted as confirmation that each individual end use is also aligned. TEUI is an aggregate metric, and similar total results can occur either because the individual end uses are closely matched or because higher values in some end uses are offset by lower values in others. A deeper exploration of the end-use breakdown is necessary to understand whether the translated hourly results reflect similar underlying energy use patterns, or whether the aggregate agreement masks differences in end uses.

Heating End Use

The translated Passive House results show the following trends:

  • Space heating demand (TEDI) remains low across all scenarios. This includes the 2021 IECC reference case. Even for the coldest climate zone, the 2021 IECC TEDI remains below 10 kBtu/ft².yr [30 kWh/m².yr], which is relatively low for a code-based multifamily archetype that does not have the same high-performance enclosure and airtightness assumptions as the Passive House cases. This reflects the influence of the higher 2021 IECC internal gains from plug loads, fans and lighting, which help reduce the heating demand even where enclosure performance is less stringent than the Passive House scenarios.
  • Passive House scenarios have lower space heating demand (TEDI), irrespective of the software used, compared to IECC. The gap between the IECC and Passive House TEDI results increases in colder climates. This trend is expected, as heating demand becomes more sensitive to enclosure performance, airtightness, and ventilation heat recovery as outdoor conditions become more severe.

Table 5.1 summarizes further analysis on a software-by-software basis, focusing on climate zones 5 to 7. The findings for these colder climate zones starting with PHPP (PHI Classic scenarios). Figure 5.11 isolates Chicago (climate zone 5) as an example for the heating end use analysis. Table 5.2 and Figure 5.12 provide a similar summary for the WUFI Passive (Phius 2024 Core) scenarios.

Table 5.1 Translated energy model results – PHI Classic (climate zones 5 to 7)

Element IECC 2021 compared to PHI (in PHPP) PHI (in E+) compared to PHI (in PHPP)

TEDI

PHI Classic TEDI values (in PHPP) lower than IECC TEDI values by 2–2.5x.

  • Hourly TEDI values for PHI Classic scenarios close to PHPP TEDI range (slightly higher). Small difference in absolute terms (< 2 kBtu/ft².yr [5 kWh/m².yr]).

Heating Equipment

Gas-based

Heat pump

Heating End Use

PHI Classic heating end use (in PHPP) lower than IECC heating end use by 5–6x.

Explanation: higher space heating demand with low efficiency equipment.

Similar heating end use for PHI Classic scenarios (in both E+ and PHPP).

Explanation: similar space heating demand and equipment efficiency.

Figure 5.11: Performance metrics of IECC scenarios in climate zone 5A [Chicago] against PHI Classic scenarios, in both PHPP and hourly software.
Figure 5.11. Performance metrics of IECC scenarios in climate zone 5A [Chicago] against PHI Classic scenarios, in both PHPP and hourly software.

Table 5.2 Translated energy model results – Phius 2024 Core (climate zones 5 to 7)

Element IECC 2021 compared to Phius (in W-PH) Phius (in E+) compared to Phius (in W-PH)

TEDI

Phius 2024 Core TEDI values (in W-PH) lower than IECC TEDI values by 1.5–2x.

  • Wider difference between Phius 2024 Core hourly TEDIs and to W-PH TEDIs (up to 4 kBtu/ft².yr [12 kWh/m².yr] in the coldest climate zone).
  • Hourly TEDI values for Phius 2024 Core scenarios closer to the IECC 2021 TEDI range (than W-PH TEDI range), slightly lower than IECC 2021 TEDI values, so much higher than Phius 2024 Core TEDI values in W-PH. Phius 2024 Core hourly TEDI values are higher than the PHI Classic TEDI values, due to higher enclosure heat losses in the Phius 2024 Core results (which are partially offset by higher plug loads).
  • Small reduction in absolute terms from 2021 IECC from Phius 2024 Core TEDI values (maintained under 20% difference, i.e., 2 kBtu/ft².yr [4 kWh/m².yr]).

Heating Equipment

Gas-based

Heat pump

Heating End Use

Phius 2024 Core heating end use (in W-PH) lower than IECC heating end use by 4–5x.

Explanation: higher space heating demand with low efficiency equipment

Similar heating end use for Phius 2024 Core scenarios (E+ values being slightly higher than PHPP values).

Explanation: similar equipment efficiency for both Phius 2024 Core scenarios.

Figure 5.12: Performance metrics of IECC scenarios in climate zone 5A [Chicago] against Phius 2024 Core scenarios, in both W-PH and hourly software.
Figure 5.12. Performance metrics of IECC scenarios in climate zone 5A [Chicago] against Phius 2024 Core scenarios, in both W-PH and hourly software.

Cooling End Use

The translated Passive House results show the following trends:

  • Passive House scenarios have lower space cooling demand (CEDI), irrespective of the software used, compared to IECC. The gap between the IECC and Passive House CEDI results increases in warmer climates. This trend is expected, as cooling demand becomes more sensitive to enclosure performance, airtightness, and ventilation heat recovery as outdoor conditions become more severe, alongside higher 2021 IECC internal heat gains (from plug loads, fans, lighting).

Further analysis is done on a software-by-software basis, focusing on climate zones 1 to 3. Table 5.3 summarizes the findings for the warmer climate zones starting with PHPP (PHI Classic scenarios). Figure 5.13 presents Atlanta (climate zone 3) to illustrate the cooling end use analysis. Table 5.4 and Figure 5.14 focuses on the WUFI Passive (Phius 2024 Core scenarios).

Table 5.3 Translated energy model results – PHI Classic (climate zones 1 to 3)

Element IECC 2021 compared to PHI (in PHPP) PHI (in E+) compared to PHI (in PHPP)

CEDI

PHI Classic CEDI values (in PHPP) lower than IECC CEDI values by 2.5–4x.

  • Hourly CEDI values for PHI Classic scenarios close to PHPP CEDI range, slightly higher than PHPP CEDI values.
  • Noticeable difference in absolute terms (up to 4 kBtu/ft².yr [13 kWh/m².yr] CEDI increase from PHPP CEDI values).

Cooling Equipment

Heat pump equipment

  • Partial load modeled
  • Seasonal COP: 4–6

Heat pump equipment

  • Partial load not modeled
  • Seasonal COP: 3

Cooling End Use

PHI Classic cooling end use (in PHPP) lower than IECC cooling end use by 1.4–1.7x.

Explanation: Higher space cooling demand with higher efficiency equipment.

Similar cooling end use for PHI Classic scenarios (in both E+ and PHPP), with Hourly CEDI values in E+ higher than the PHPP CEDI values (difference kept under 35% difference, i.e. 2 kBtu/ft².yr [5 kWh/m².yr]).

Explanation: Cooling end use in a similar range between scenarios due to similar space cooling demand and equipment efficiency.

Figure 5.13: Performance metrics of IECC scenarios in climate zone 3A [Atlanta] against PHI Classic scenarios, in both PHPP and hourly software.
Figure 5.13. Performance metrics of IECC scenarios in climate zone 3A [Atlanta] against PHI Classic scenarios, in both PHPP and hourly software.

Table 5.4 Translated energy model results – Phius 2024 Core (climate zones 1 to 3)

Element IECC 2021 compared to Phius (in W-PH) Phius (in E+) compared to Phius (in W-PH)

CEDI

Phius 2024 Core CEDI values (in W-PH) lower than IECC CEDI values by 2–3x.

  • Hourly CEDI values for Phius 2024 Core scenarios close to W-PH CEDI range, slightly higher than W-PH CEDI values.
  • Noticeable difference in absolute terms (up to 6 kBtu/ft².yr [17 kWh/m².yr] CEDI increase from PHPP CEDI values).

Cooling Equipment

Heat pump equipment

  • Partial load modeled
  • Seasonal COP: 4–6

Heat pump equipment

  • Partial load not modeled
  • Seasonal COP: 3

Cooling End Use

Phius 2024 Core cooling end use (in W-PH) lower than IECC cooling end use by 1.2–1.6x.

Explanation: Higher space cooling demand with higher efficiency equipment.

Similar cooling end use for Phius 2024 Core scenarios (in both E+ and W-PH), with Hourly CEDI values in E+ higher than the W-PH CEDI values (difference kept under 35% difference, i.e., 2 kBtu/ft².yr [4 kWh/m².yr]).

Explanation: Cooling end use in a similar range between scenarios due to similar space cooling demand and equipment efficiency.

Figure 5.14: Performance metrics of IECC scenarios in climate zone 3A [Atlanta] against Phius 2024 Core scenarios, in both W-PH and hourly software.
Figure 5.14. Performance metrics of IECC scenarios in climate zone 3A [Atlanta] against Phius 2024 Core scenarios, in both W-PH and hourly software.

Other End Uses

Table 5.5 summarizes the remaining end uses that contribute to the total energy consumption beyond space heating and cooling. These end uses are compared between the IECC 2021 case against the Passive House scenarios (in both Passive House and Hourly software). Figure 5.15 illustrates the same comparison graphically, helping to show which end uses drive the differences between the modeled scenarios.

Figure 5.15: End Use breakdown of IECC scenarios, Passive House scenarios in both Passive House and hourly software in climate zone 3A [Atlanta].
Figure 5.15. End Use breakdown of IECC scenarios, Passive House scenarios in both Passive House and hourly software in climate zone 3A [Atlanta].

Table 5.5 Translated energy model results – PHI Classic & Phius 2024 Core

End Use IECC 2021 compared to PHI (in PHPP or E+) IECC 2021 compared to Phius (in W-PH or E+)

Lighting

Impact: Small energy use (<10%)

Values: PHI Classic ~70% reduction from IECC 2021 (2021 IECC >> PHI Classic)

Findings: Significant difference between IECC 2021 and PHI Classic lighting energy consumption.

Impact: Small energy use (<10%)

Values: Phius 2024 Core ~70% reduction from IECC 2021 (2021 IECC >> Phius 2024 Core)

Findings: Significant difference between IECC 2021 and PHI Classic lighting energy consumption.

Plug Loads

Impact: Large energy use (>30%)

Values: PHI Classic ~65% reduction from IECC 2021, which represents a 7 kBtu/ft².yr [23 kWh/m².yr] gap (2021 IECC >> PHI Classic).

Findings: Significant difference between IECC 2021 and PHI Classic plug loads energy consumption. PHI Classic approach: best practice at a global level, which is noticeably lower than the average plug load energy consumption in North America.

Impact: Large energy use (>30%)

Values: Phius 2024 Core ~50% reduction from IECC 2021, which represents a 5 kBtu/ft².yr [17 kWh/m².yr] gap (2021 IECC >> Phius 2024 Core).

Findings: Significant difference between IECC 2021 and Phius 2024 Core plug loads energy consumption. Phius approach in Multi-Family typology: calculated at 80% of RESNET (2013) levels of “Rated Home” for dwelling units, and other protocols for other spaces.

Elevators

Impact: Small energy use (<10%)

Values: PHI Classic ~35% reduction from IECC 2021

Findings: PHI elevator energy consumption calculator aligned with industry assumptions, with higher performance requirements for energy savings.

Impact: Small energy use (<10%)

Values: Phius 2024 Core ~85% reduction from IECC 2021 (2021 IECC >> Phius 2024 Core)

Findings: Phius elevator energy consumption calculator with smaller energy consumption than IECC and PHI.

Pumps

Impact: Minor energy use (<1%)

Values: 2021 IECC << PHI Classic

Findings: Limited inputs to capture pump controls in Passive House software.

Impact: Minor energy use (<1%)

Values: 2021 IECC << Phius 2024 Core

Findings: Limited inputs to capture pump controls in Passive House software.

Fans

Impact: Small energy use (<10%)

Values: PHI Classic (in PHPP) ~55–60% reduction from IECC 2021 (2021 IECC >> PHI Classic)

Findings – PHI vs IECC: PHI Classic fan energy consumption is significantly lower than 2021 IECC due to the combination to the following factors, leading to significant savings:

  • Lower cooling demand (cooling demand reduced by 2.5–4x from 2021 IECC CEDI)
  • Lower ventilation rates (outdoor air flow rates reduced by ~20% from 2021 IECC values)
  • Lower ventilation fan efficiency, reduced by ~40% from 2021 IECC values)

Findings – PHI in PHPP vs E+: PHI Classic fan energy consumption in E+ is further reduced from PHI Classic fan energy consumption in PHPP, due to the granularity of the hourly modeling approach, calling on heating and cooling fans (in the fan coil units) as needed, though PHPP model inputs are tied to space heating/cooling demand.

  • PHI Classic fan energy in E+ ~35–50% reduction from PHI Classic fan energy in PHPP.

Impact: Small energy use (<10%)

Values: Phius 2024 Core ~35–60% reduction from IECC 2021 (2021 IECC >> Phius 2024 Core)

Findings – Phius vs IECC: Phius 2024 Core fan energy consumption is significantly lower than the 2021 IECC due to the combination to the following factors, leading to significant savings:

  • Lower cooling demand (cooling demand reduced by 2.5–3x from 2021 IECC CEDI)
  • Lower ventilation rates (outdoor air flow rates reduced by ~20% from 2021 IECC values)
  • Lower ventilation fan efficiency, reduced by ~40% from 2021 IECC values)

Findings – Phius in W-PH vs E+: Phius 2024 Core fan energy consumption in E+ is further reduced from Phius 2024 Core fan energy consumption in W-PH, due to the granularity of the hourly modeling approach, calling on heating and cooling fans (in the fan coil units) as needed (note: W-PH model inputs are independent from space heating/cooling demand, hence seeing a wider variation between Passive House scenarios in W-PH and E+, compared to the PHI Classic scenarios).

  • Phius 2024 Core fan energy in E+ ~40–50% reduction from Phius 2024 Core fan energy in W-PH.

DHW

Impact: Large energy use (>10% in warmer climates, >30% in cold climates)

Values: PHI Classic (in PHPP) ~45–80% reduction from IECC 2021 (2021 IECC >> PHI Classic)

Findings – PHI vs IECC: PHI Classic DHW energy consumption is significantly lower than 2021 IECC due to the combination to the following factors, leading to significant savings:

  • Lower DHW demand (DHW demand reduced by 65% from 2021 IECC, though gap reduced due to DHW distribution and storage heat losses)
  • More efficient DHW energy system:
    • Passive House scenarios: heat pump
    • 2021 IECC climate zones 1–4: heat pump (leading to 45% energy savings)
    • 2021 IECC climate zones 5–7: electric resistance (leading to 80% energy savings)

Findings – PHI in PHPP vs E+: PHI Classic DHW energy consumption in E+ is further reduced, slightly, from PHI Classic DHW energy consumption in PHPP. This difference might be due to the difference in climate files, where the ground water temperature impacts the DHW energy consumption.

Impact: Large energy use (>10% in warmer climates, >30% in cold climates)

Values: Phius 2024 Core (in W-PH) ~65–90% reduction from IECC 2021 (2021 IECC >> Phius 2024 Core)

Findings – Phius vs IECC: Phius 2024 Core DHW energy consumption is significantly lower than 2021 IECC due to the combination to the following factors, leading to significant savings:

  • Lower DHW demand (DHW demand reduced by 75% from 2021 IECC, though gap reduced due to DHW distribution and storage heat losses)
  • More efficient DHW energy system:
    • Passive House scenarios: heat pump
    • 2021 IECC climate zones 1–4: heat pump (leading to 65% energy savings)
    • 2021 IECC climate zones 5–7: direct electric (leading to 90% energy savings)

Findings – PHI in PHPP vs E+: Phius 2024 Core DHW energy consumption in E+ is slightly increased from Phius 2024 Core DHW energy consumption in W-PH. This difference might be due to the difference in climate files, where the ground water temperature impacts the DHW energy consumption.

6. Conclusions and Recommendations

6.1. Findings

This study confirms that Passive House scenarios produce materially better energy performance outcomes through climate zones 1 to 7, compared with the 2021 IECC, ASHRAE 90.1-2016 Appendix G, and ASHRAE 90.1-2019 Appendix G baseline scenarios for the multifamily archetype reviewed. The findings also show that meaningful comparison requires clarity on both the modeling tool and the standard or protocol being applied, as each framework embeds different assumptions, default values, normalization areas, and treatment of energy losses.

Key finding 1: Passive House shows a significant reduction in energy use, consistently across climate zones.

  • As presented in Figure 5.9, across the initial comparison, Passive House TEUI results are close to 13 kBtu/ft².yr [40 kWh/m².yr] and stable across climate zones 1 to 7, compared with baseline hourly model results ranging from approximately 29 to 57 kBtu/ft².yr [90 to 180 kWh/m².yr]. This represents an approximate 2x to 4.5x improvement in TEUI, depending on climate zone and baseline scenario.
  • The gap is driven by the combined impact of lower space heating and cooling demand, high-performance enclosure assumptions, airtightness, ventilation heat recovery, efficient equipment, and reduced regulated and unregulated loads.
  • The TEDI and CEDI results (Figures 5.7 and 5.8) show that Passive House scenarios reduce space conditioning demand, not only total energy use. This reduction in TEDI/CEDI becomes more pronounced the higher the demand climates, i.e., cold/warm climates.

Key finding 2: The Passive House-to-hourly translation workflow produced comparable whole-building TEUI results, with notable, software-specific differences at the TEDI, CEDI and end-use level.

  • The alignment of Passive House-level performance results across modeling tools suggests that, when Passive House inputs and protocols are carefully normalized and translated into hourly model inputs, EnergyPlus can be configured to reproduce Passive House-level performance TEUI results with a high degree of consistency (Section 5.5). The outcome supports the use of the translation workflow as a reasonable method for comparing whole-building energy outcomes across tools, within the limitations of each modeling platform.
  • The alignment of Passive House energy performance (TEUI) results across modeling software should not be treated to mean alignment of TEDI and CEDI metrics between tools.
  • On the heating demand side:
    • The translated hourly TEDI results remain close to the PHPP TEDI results, for the PHI Classic scenarios. The hourly results are slightly higher, but the difference remains small in absolute terms, under 2 kBtu/ft².yr [5 kWh/m².yr] for the coldest climate zone, where the gap is the largest. This indicates that the translation workflow captures the PHPP heating demand reasonably well across software platforms.
    • The TEDI comparison shows a wider software-to-software difference for Phius 2024 Core. The hourly results are higher, reaching up to a 4 kBtu/ft².yr [12 kWh/m².yr] TEDI (~85%) increase in the coldest climate zone, which is significant when dealing with low TEDI values (under 5 kBtu/ft².yr [15 kWh/m².yr]) on Passive House scenarios. This suggests that the W-PH heating demand result is more sensitive to differences in the software engines, enclosure heat loss treatment, internal gains, and hourly heat balance calculations.
  • On the cooling demand side:
    • Both PHPP and W-PH translated hourly results are close to the corresponding Passive House software results range, consistently a little higher than the respective PHPP and W-PH results. This difference reaches around 30% increase from the Passive House software results (which represents an increase of 4-5 kBtu/ft².yr [13-17 kWh/m².yr] CEDI

increase in absolute terms). This is an expected outcome, knowing the hourly model has a more granular, zone-by-zone, hourly-step approach to cooling demand calculations.

Key finding 3: Plug loads, lighting, elevators, and DHW assumptions have a significant influence on TEUI, across modeling protocols, and should not be treated as neutral background inputs.

  • The end-use comparison shows substantial differences in assumed plug load (with plug loads being one of the largest end use in the Passive House scenarios), lighting, and elevator energy use between the baseline hourly models and Passive House scenarios. These end uses also influence internal heat gains, which in turn affect TEDI and CEDI results.
  • The real-world alignment of these assumptions is external to the scope of this study. However, it is worth noting the large range associated with each end-use input, which could be reduced by having a better understanding of average end-use energy consumption for this archetype.

Key finding 4: The baseline PNNL prototype files are useful for comparison, but should not be assumed to represent real projects built to these standards.

  • The PNNL prototype files provide an established, industry-approved baseline for analysis, but the review identified inconsistencies and assumptions that may not fully reflect current multifamily design practice or the range of project-specific choices made under IECC or ASHRAE compliance pathways.

Key finding 5: The choice of software and protocol materially affects reported outcomes.

  • The different modeling scenarios show that the selected standard and protocol drive the modeling methodologies and associated input values used in the software, and therefore impact the resulting performance metrics.
  • Passive House tools and protocols place greater emphasis on airtightness verification, thermal bridging accounting, and the explicit accounting of hydronic distribution and installation losses. Hourly models provide more granularity through hourly time-steps, zoning (multi-zones), and HVAC systems able to capture part-load characteristics, but exclude or simplify loss mechanisms on certain elements.
  • Modeling methodologies use different floor area for normalization, this should be adjusted to allow for a like-for-like comparison of results.
  • For policy and program design, typical modeling results should therefore be seen within a “tool + modeling protocol” context (rather than as software outputs alone), when a rigorous, normalized comparison isn’t performed. Tool and modeling protocols should also be explicitly named when looking at any energy model results.

Implication for policy makers, programs, and lending institutions

For policy makers, the results (extending through TEUI, TEDI and CEDI results) provide clear evidence that Passive House can deliver substantially lower modeled energy use than the commonly referenced code and program baselines of 2021 IECC, ASHRAE 90.1-2016 and 2019 Appendix G for the multifamily archetype. These results extend to the TEDI and CEDI metrics: Passive House materially reduces the heating and cooling loads, which is another important aspect when policy makers assess resilience, peak load reduction and electrification readiness.

Based on the magnitude and consistency of the modeled performance gap observed across climate zones, Passive House should be recognized as a robust alternative compliance pathway for policies, incentive programs, and performance-based building requirements where the objective is to achieve predictable, high-performance energy outcomes.

For banks and lending institutions, the results help quantify the performance gap between conventional code/program pathways and Passive House, while also highlighting the importance of consistent modeling assumptions when using energy performance metrics to assess risk, incentives, or financing eligibility.

6.2. Limitations and Discussions

The main limitation of this study is that the boundaries are set as a desk-based modeling study only. Modeled results are powerful because they allow multiple standards, tools, and climates to be compared under controlled assumptions. They also make it possible to isolate the influence of specific modeling protocols and input assumptions in a way that would be difficult using field data alone.

However, modeled results do not capture the full range of factors that influence actual building performance, including construction quality, commissioning outcomes, controls setup, and occupant behavior. The reported TEDI, CEDI, and TEUI values should be understood as comparative modeled outcomes rather than predictions of measured utility performance for any specific building.

Further Investigations

Further investigation would strengthen the findings by comparing the modeled results against measured building performance. The objective would be to obtain real-life data with the intent to develop similar TEUI comparison graphs using actual measured energy data from buildings designed to each scenario (PHI and Phius-compliant projects, 2021 IECC-compliant projects, and ASHRAE 90.1 2016 and 2019 Appendix G-based projects). This would help test whether the relative performance differences observed in the modeled results are reflected in operational outcomes, once buildings are occupied and operating under real-world conditions. A measured-performance comparison would therefore require careful data screening, documentation and normalization to avoid overstating or understating the performance differences between pathways, while also quantifying the performance gap between predicted and measured performance.

Actual building performance data is already available from several sources, including certified Passive House projects (under both PHI and Phius), as well as broader benchmarking platforms and disclosure datasets for non-Passive House certified buildings (such as ENERGY STAR Portfolio Manager). However, these datasets are typically dispersed, reported using different boundaries and normalization conventions, and not structured to support direct comparison by standard or certification pathways. A key next step would therefore be to amalgamate relevant, available measured-performance data and apply a consistent normalization process, before producing measured TEUI comparison graphs. This would allow the modeled trends identified in this study to be tested against actual operating performance across Passive House, IECC, and ASHRAE-based project types.

It is worth highlighting that Passive House certification includes a level of quality assurance and quality control that is not fully reflected in a desk-based energy modeling comparison. Both PHI and Phius pathways require a third-party review of the energy model and supporting documentation (throughout design and construction phases). Projects also rely on construction-phase verification processes such as airtightness testing, inspection of key enclosure and mechanical system details, enhanced commissioning, and confirmation that the built condition aligns with the design intent (certification is obtained based on the as-built energy model and supporting evidence). This embedded QA/QC process is an important differentiator: it helps reduce the gap between modeled and delivered performance and provides policymakers with greater confidence that Passive House certification represents not only a modeled performance target, but also a verified delivery pathway.

A second area for further investigation is measured end-use performance through a measurement and verification process. While whole-building TEUI is often the most accessible measured metric, more granular end-use data would provide deeper insight into the drivers of actual energy use. Sub-metered or otherwise disaggregated data for plug loads, lighting, elevators, and domestic hot water would help assess how the vast input range for these end-uses relates to average measured end-use loads and associated energy consumption.

This work would help bridge the gap between compliance modeling and operational outcomes, while also identifying where differences in available data quality or reporting methods may limit comparability.

See the research

In PHN Presents: Multifamily Buildings Energy Standards Report, report author Marine Sanchez of RDH and PHN Policy Director Bronwyn Barry present the methods, the findings, the translation workflow behind them, and what they mean for accepting Passive House as an alternative compliance pathway.

Watch it free on YouTube, or see its page in the training catalog.

Questions about the study: contact us.

Checked November 2026.